All Island Blog

Experience the Best of LI Nightlife at these Wantagh Bars

Posted by Collin McGorty on Mar 13, 2019 9:00:00 AM

Wantagh Bars

In most towns and neighborhoods, you usually know what kind of bars to expect. However, in a place like Wantagh, there are watering holes for every type of drinker, from Irish pubs to cocktail lounges and All-American taprooms. So, if you find yourself on the South Shore in the near future, these fun, welcoming Wantagh bars are always good for a drink or two.

All Island’s Definitive Guide to the Top Wantagh Bars


No list of the top Wantagh bars would be complete without the addition of a pillar of Long Island nightlife, Mulcahy’s. For over 50 years, Mulcahy’s has been the area’s go-to spot for “Good, Clean Fun.”

Not to mention, they’re also one of Long Island’s most popular live music venues. Over the years, they’ve hosted plenty of acts, from local bands like Mike Delguidice and Big Shot to global sensations like Third Eye Blind and the Dropkick Murphy’s.

So, whether you’re looking to simply enjoy a few drinks with friends or make it an evening to remember, Mulcahy’s is the bar for you. They also have plenty of huge TVs, making it the ideal spot for any sporting event.

Wantagh Bars

Bunker Hill American Taproom

Bunker Hill American Taproom is the newest Wantagh bar on the scene. Located in the heart of town, just a few steps from the train station, this warm, inviting pub specializes in burgers and craft beer, with over 20 different rotating brews on tap.

Their menu offers the usual pub fare that you’d expect, with the addition of upscale dishes that will leave you wanting more. They also have a kids menu and plenty of gluten-free options. However, their top dishes include:

  • Mini Smoked Sausage Corn Dogs
  • General Washington Burger (Braised short rib, caramelized onion jam, white cheddar)
  • Buttermilk Fried Chicken & Biscuit
  • Grilled Coffee-Rubbed Tri-Tip

If you’re visiting Bunker Hill, we recommend coming by on Wednesday for Taps and Apps. From 5 p.m. to midnight, they offer $4 tap beers like Blue Point and Kona, in addition to $6 appetizers like Smoked Paprika Potato Chips and Shishito Peppers.

Wantagh Bars

Blackbird Kitchen & Cocktails

Last but not least is Blackbird Kitchen & Cocktails, otherwise known as one of the best places to eat and drink in Wantagh. In fact, every one of their wines, craft beers and cocktails pairs perfectly with a menu selection.

As one of Long Island’s most progressive restaurants, Blackbird is committed to serving New-American small plates sourced from local farms and suppliers. In fact, here are a few of their fan favorites:

  • Chick Pea Spiced Hummus
  • Day Boat Sea Scallops
  • Spanish Octopus
  • Braised Heritage Pork Meatballs

Just remember, this Wantagh bar can get quite busy, so make your reservation today.

Wantagh Bars

Even though these three are the best of the best, there are more than a few solid Wantagh bars, so go out and start discovering them!

Subscribe to Our Newsletter to Receive Updates, Coupons and More!

Topics: Nightlife, Food & Drink, Bars

Sign Up for our monthly newsletter Today!

The All Islander

Our Monthly Newsletter gives you updates about events and activities on Long Island.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter to Receive Updates, Coupons and More!

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

see all