All Island Blog

Scenic Fire Island Restaurants for a Delicious Seaside Meal

Posted by Collin McGorty on Jul 11, 2018 9:00:00 AM

Fire Island Restaurants

It’s no surprise that Fire Island has some of the most gorgeous, pristine beaches on all of Long Island. But, did you know that it’s also home to a flourishing food scene? Some of the top chefs and restauranteurs have decided to take their talents to this beach-bum paradise for their own spin on some local favorites. So, next time you’re in the area and searching for a great meal, visit one of these tasty Fire Island restaurants.

The Definitive List of the Top Fire Island Restaurants

Surf’s Out

Surf’s Out, located on the water in Kismet, is one of the island’s top destinations for both lunch and dinner. After all, from juicy burgers to crisp salads and freshly rolled sushi, this dockside restaurant truly has it all. Not to mention, it’s one of Fire Island’s favorite venues for live music, theme nights, local DJs and out-of-this-world entertainment.

Fire Island Restaurants

Start your meal off with a delicious cocktail and appetizer from head chef Anthony Trobiano. Then, you can choose from one of their many entrée selections, such as:

  • Yellowfin Tuna
  • New York Strip Steak
  • Sweet Chili Shrimp Flatbread
  • Linguine Clam Sauce
  • Lobster Mac

Surf’s Out also has an entire menu dedicated to a wide variety of sushi and sashimi if you’re interested. Also, feel free to visit right after the beach as the restaurant has outdoor showers and lockers for your convenience. Click here to make a reservation today.


If you’ve ever partied in Fire Island, then chances are you’ve been to Flynn’s, a fixture on the local bar scene for almost eight decades. However, when it’s not being used as the local hangout spot, Flynn’s is one of the top Fire Island restaurants out there.

Fire Island Restaurants

Whether you’re sipping tropical-inspired cocktails in the lounge or dining on the bay, Flynn’s has a lively atmosphere and American fare that everyone can enjoy. Just make sure that you try one of these tasty dishes:

  • Iced Bay Clams
  • New England Lobster Roll
  • Handmade Crabcake
  • Pan-Seared Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
  • Atlantic Salmon Macadamia Crust

When all is said and done with your meal, feel free to keep the party going at Flynn’s with a few drinks and some dancing, courtesy of the area’s top DJs and performers. Just remember, it gets busy—so be sure to make a reservation ahead of time.

Casino Café

Last but not least on our list of the top Fire Island Restaurants is Davis Park’s very own Casino Café, the area’s only oceanfront restaurant since 1945. Whether you sit at an oceanside table or on the dune deck, you will be able to enjoy sprawling views of the entire Fire Island coastline.

Fire Island Restaurants

The Casino Café’s expansive menu is full of only the freshest seafood, steaks, pasta and decadent desserts. For your entrée, you can order delicious selections, such as:

  • Mahi Mahi Tacos
  • Pan Seared Sea Scallops
  • Pappardelle Bolognese
  • Hoisin Glazed Duck Breast
  • Grill Marinated Shell Steak

You truly won’t find a better view at any of the other Fire Island restaurants.

If you find yourself hungry in Fire Island, make your way to one of these incredibly delicious restaurants.

Make an Online Reservation Today!

Topics: Food & Drink, Fire Island, restaurants

Sign Up for our monthly newsletter Today!

The All Islander

Our Monthly Newsletter gives you updates about events and activities on Long Island.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter to Receive Updates, Coupons and More!

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

see all